STUDIA SOCIOLOGIA - Recenzare

STUDIA SOCIOLOGIA

RECENZARE

DESCRIEREA PROCESULUI DE RECENZARE

Articolele sunt recenzate de către 2 recenzori din afara Universităţii Babeş-Bolyai, care completează un formular de recenzie standard. Sugestiile acestora sunt trimise autorului, pentru eventuale modificări. Recenzorii nu cunosc numele autorului, la fel cum autorul nu cunoaşte numele recenzorilor (double blind review system).

REVIEW FORM FOR STUDIA SOCIOLOGIA

TITLE OF THE ARTICLE REVIEWED:

NAME OF THE REVIEWER (TO BE DELETED BY EDITORS):

1. Please evaluate the article according to the following criteria:

Mark with X one box per line!	Very poor	Poor	Acceptable	Good	Very good	Excellent
1. Theoretical grounding
2. Adequate use of up-to-date literature
3. Structure of the paper
4. Quality of conceptualisations
5. Research design
6. Quality of the empirical material
7. Empirical data analysis
8. Interpretation of empirical findings
9. Quality of argumentation
10. Clarity of arguments
11. Coherence of the argumentation
12. Originality
13. Scholarly contribution
14. Overall evaluation of the paper
15. Quality of using the English language

2. Evaluation and feedback (300-500 words).

1. General evaluation.

2. Observations, critiques.

3. Suggestions for improving the paper.

3. Message for editors – please mark with X your opinion!

This article should be…	Rejected	Substantially revised and re-submitted	Slightly revised and re-submitted	Accepted with only minor changes	Accepted as it is

4. Other observations, comments.

…………………………………………………………………………………………